#3d Deep Study Pages / The Mind

The Mind

The mind is a brilliant worker that needs a job. This page looks at how it thinks, what clouds it, how it goes wrong, and how to give it good work and good rest.

The mind is the fourth part of SEEMS. The Gateway page on the mind showed that the mind is wonderful when it has a real task and troublesome when it is left to run by itself. This Deep Study page walks through the same six topics as the pages on the senses, the ego, and the emotions, this time with the research behind them. We will look at what the mind really does, how the body and our beliefs change it, what brain injury and mental illness reveal, how it works with the other four parts, and what helps it work better. Along the way we will see that good thinking has a lot in common with good writing.

Begin Reading ↓

Companion Gateway Page

This page goes with the Gateway page Mind. Each section here matches a section there, so you can move back and forth between the simple version and the deeper one.

A Brilliant Worker That Needs a Job

R-Page 03, The Five Pillars, described the mind as an inner voice that seems never to stop. It narrates, compares, plans, and explains. It can reason carefully and solve hard problems. The mind is the part of us that builds a house, figures out a tax form, repairs a radio, and writes a letter. Nearly everything people have made, from the wheel to the space telescope, began as a thought in somebody's mind.

But the mind has a strange habit. When the job is done, it does not clock out. It keeps talking anyway, and it fills the empty space with whatever happens to be lying around. Most of this page is about that difference between a mind with a job and a mind without one.

One Thought at a Time

The mind works in a very narrow channel. In 1956 the psychologist George Miller wrote a famous paper arguing that we can hold only about seven items in mind at once. In 2001 Nelson Cowan reviewed the evidence again and concluded that the real number is closer to four. This small workbench is called working memory. It is where the mind lays out the pieces of whatever it is working on, and it fills up quickly. That is why we can remember a phone number long enough to dial it and then lose it the moment someone asks us a question.

R-Page 10, Inner Energy, explained that the mind can hold only one active thought at a time, even though the emotions can run several at once. What feels like doing two things at once is really switching back and forth very fast. In 2001 Joshua Rubinstein, David Meyer, and Jeffrey Evans measured what that switching costs. Every switch took extra time, and the cost grew as the tasks got harder. A person who answers email during a meeting is not doing two jobs. That person is doing two half-jobs, with a small delay each time the mind changes tracks.

Five Ways the Mind Runs

The Gateway page described five ways to understand the mind. They are not five separate minds. They are five ways the same mind behaves, depending on what is guiding it.

Directed Mind

The mind has a real task. It organizes facts, solves problems, learns, creates, and bears fruit.

Idle Mind

The mind has no task but keeps running anyway. It comments, worries, compares, and invents little stories.

Subconscious

When the mind is idle, the subconscious often supplies its material. It replays old pain, looks for danger, and rehearses trouble that has not happened.

Primitive Mind

Inside the subconscious, an older system offers quick answers to problems that really need slow thought.

Resting Mind

The mind is given something peaceful to rest on, such as the breath, a repeated phrase, or simple listening. It settles, and the soul can watch.

Fast Thinking and Slow Thinking

The psychologist Daniel Kahneman won a Nobel Prize for his work on how people make judgments. In his 2011 book Thinking, Fast and Slow, he described two ways of thinking. Fast thinking is automatic. It recognizes a friend's face, finishes the phrase "bread and," and senses anger in a voice, all without effort. Slow thinking is deliberate. It adds up a column of numbers, compares two insurance plans, and checks whether an argument holds together. Fast thinking is quick and usually right about familiar things. Slow thinking takes effort, and the mind avoids it whenever it can. The primitive quick-solution mind described on the Gateway page is fast thinking used on a problem that needed slow thinking. Try this small puzzle, which the psychologist Shane Frederick made famous in 2005.

A bat and a ball cost $1.10 together. The bat costs $1.00 more than the ball. How much does the ball cost?

Show the answer

The answer that jumps to mind is ten cents, but it is wrong. If the ball cost ten cents, the bat would cost $1.10, and the two together would cost $1.20. The ball costs five cents, and the bat costs $1.05. Frederick found that about half of the students he tested at some of the best universities in America gave the quick wrong answer. The fast mind offered an answer, and the slow mind never checked it.

The Mind as Dispatcher

R-Page 04, Triggers and Beliefs, described the mind as a dispatcher. When something happens, the mind decides what it means and sends that reading out to the ego, the emotions, and the senses. The page followed a single remark down two roads. When the mind read it as a joke, everyone relaxed. When the mind read the same words as an insult, the ego got ready to defend, the emotions moved toward anger, and the senses watched for more trouble. Nothing about the words had changed. Only the mind's story had changed. This is one reason the mind matters so much. The other parts live inside whatever story it tells.

The Mind Is Always Guessing

R-Page 08b, AI and the Mind, began with the jolt we feel when we reach for a stair that isn't there. The brain had already guessed where the stair would be and moved the foot to meet it. Neuroscientists call this predictive processing. The brain is always guessing what comes next and checking its guesses against what the senses report. Most of the time the guesses are good, and we never notice them. But it means that the mind does not simply see the world. It sees its best guess about the world, and that guess is built from everything it has learned before.

The Idle Mind Is Not Idle

In 2001 Marcus Raichle and his colleagues at Washington University in St. Louis noticed something odd in brain scans. Certain areas of the brain became more active, not less, when people stopped doing a task and simply lay in the scanner. Raichle named this the default mode network. It is the brain's own idle setting, and it is busy with thoughts about ourselves, memories of the past, and plans and worries about the future. In 2010 Matthew Killingsworth and Daniel Gilbert at Harvard used a phone app to ask thousands of people what they were doing and what they were thinking about at random moments of the day. Their minds were wandering away from what they were doing almost half the time, and they were less happy while their minds wandered, even when the wandering went somewhere pleasant. The researchers summed it up in the title of their paper, which was "A Wandering Mind Is an Unhappy Mind."

Diagram of where the mind goes with and without a task A box labeled The Mind sits at the top. One arrow goes down to the left, labeled given a real task, to a box labeled Directed Mind, which solves, learns, and builds, and bears fruit. Another arrow goes down to the right, labeled left with no task, to a box labeled Idle Mind. From the Idle Mind, one arrow labeled by habit leads to a box labeled Subconscious, with worry, loops, and old pain. A second arrow labeled by choice leads to a box labeled The Soul, with rest and quiet watching. The Mind given a real task left with no task Directed Mind solves, learns, builds bears fruit Idle Mind no task, still running by habit by choice Subconscious worry, loops, old pain The Soul rest, quiet watching

A mind with a real task bears fruit. A mind with no task keeps running, and by habit it drifts into the subconscious. With practice, we can choose instead to hand the empty space to the soul.

When the Mind Leads Without the Soul

R-Page 03 called this the most subtle way for a life to go wrong, because from the outside it looks like wisdom. A clever mind can build an argument for almost anything. The psychologist Jonathan Haidt, in his 2012 book The Righteous Mind, compared our reasoning to a press secretary. A press secretary's job is not to decide what the government should do. It is to explain and defend whatever the government has already decided. Haidt found that much of our everyday reasoning works the same way. A feeling or a wish makes the decision first, and then the mind steps up to the microphone to explain why the decision was right. Without the soul's honest direction, the mind becomes a very skilled lawyer for whatever the ego and the emotions already wanted.

The Body Sets the Floor

The brain weighs about two percent of the body, but it uses about twenty percent of the body's energy. A hungry engine runs rough, and so does a hungry, tired, or poisoned brain. The mind feels like something above the body, but it depends on the body every second. When the body is short of sleep, food, oxygen, or calm, the mind is the first to show it, often before we notice anything else is wrong.

Sleep

In 2003 Hans Van Dongen, David Dinges, and their colleagues at the University of Pennsylvania limited a group of healthy adults to six hours of sleep a night for two weeks. By the end, their attention and reaction times had slipped as badly as people who had gone two full nights without any sleep at all. The most worrying part was that the six-hour sleepers did not feel very sleepy. Their thinking had slowed, and their minds had not noticed. In 2000 Ann Williamson and Anne-Marie Feyer in Australia found that staying awake for seventeen to nineteen hours slowed people down about as much as a blood alcohol level of 0.05 percent. Sleep is also when the brain files the day's learning into long-term memory. A good night's sleep after studying is part of the studying.

Stress Shrinks the Thinking

A little stress sharpens the mind, and a lot of it shuts down the best part. In 2009 the neuroscientist Amy Arnsten of Yale described what happens. Under strong stress, the body releases chemicals that switch off much of the prefrontal cortex, the area just behind the forehead that plans, weighs choices, and holds back impulses. Control passes to older and faster parts of the brain that act on habit and reflex. In real danger this makes sense, because jumping out of the way of a truck is better than thinking about it. But it also explains why we say foolish things in an argument and only think of the wise answer on the drive home. Strong stress hands the steering wheel to the primitive quick-solution mind.

Movement and Age

The body can build the mind up as well as wear it down. In 2011 Kirk Erickson and his colleagues asked a group of older adults to take brisk walks three times a week for a year. Brain scans showed that the hippocampus, an area that helps form new memories, grew by about two percent. That is roughly the amount it normally shrinks in one to two years of aging, so the walking turned the clock back.

Age changes the mind in two different ways. Psychologists Raymond Cattell and John Horn divided intelligence into two kinds. Fluid intelligence is the ability to solve new puzzles quickly, and it slowly declines from early adulthood on. Crystallized intelligence is knowledge, vocabulary, and the hard-won judgment of experience, and it keeps growing well into later life. An older mind may take longer to learn a new phone, but it often sees the whole picture of a problem faster than a younger one. Speed fades first. Wisdom stays much longer.

Chemistry Does Not Treat the Five Parts the Same

The Emotions Deep Study page noted that alcohol lifts the emotions while it dulls the mind. This is a good example of a larger rule. Brain chemistry does not raise or lower all five parts of SEEMS together. Caffeine sharpens the mind and the senses but can make the emotions jumpy. Some medicines calm the emotions but leave the mind foggy. Each part has its own sensitivity, and the mind is often the one that pays the bill for what the emotions enjoyed.

Alcohol and Drugs

Alcohol slows down the front of the brain early, before it slows anything else very much. This is why judgment leaves the party before the slurred speech arrives. A person who has had a few drinks can still talk and walk, but the part of the mind that says "Maybe this isn't a good idea" has already gone quiet. In 1990 Claude Steele and Robert Josephs called this effect alcohol myopia, which means nearsightedness. Alcohol narrows the mind's view to whatever is most obvious right now, such as an insult, a temptation, or the next drink, and it hides the consequences waiting down the road. With heavier drinking, the brain's recording system can stop working altogether. A person in a blackout is awake and talking, but nothing is being saved, and the next morning there is simply a gap. Years of heavy drinking can rob the body of the vitamin thiamine, and in some people this leads to a lasting memory disorder called Korsakoff syndrome, which we will meet again in Section 4.

Other drugs act on the mind in their own ways. Marijuana weakens short-term memory and attention while a person is high. In 2012 Madeline Meier and her colleagues followed about a thousand people in New Zealand from childhood to age thirty-eight. Those who began heavy use as teenagers and kept it up lost several IQ points over the years, while people who never used it did not. In 2019 Marta Di Forti and her colleagues found that people who used high-strength marijuana every day were about five times more likely to develop psychosis, a condition in which the mind loses touch with what is real. Stimulants such as cocaine and methamphetamine first make the mind feel sharp and confident, but heavy use can bring on suspicion and paranoid thinking. Opioids blanket the mind in fog. Even ordinary prescription medicines can cloud thinking, especially in older people. The American Geriatrics Society keeps a list, called the Beers Criteria, of medicines that are risky for older adults, and many sleeping pills, allergy pills, and bladder medicines are on it because they can bring on confusion. Anyone who notices new forgetfulness or fog after starting a medicine should mention it to a doctor or pharmacist.

What lowers the floor

A Foggier Mind

Short sleep, strong stress, skipped meals, illness, alcohol, recreational drugs, and some medicines all slow the mind and hand more control to its quick, primitive habits.

What raises it

A Clearer Mind

Good sleep, regular meals, plenty of water, daily movement, time outdoors, and a careful look at our medicines give the mind a steadier floor to think on.

Beliefs Are Stabilized Thoughts

The Gateway page described a belief as a thought that has been accepted as true and no longer feels like a thought. A passing thought says, "Maybe people don't like me." A belief says, "People don't like me." The second one has stopped asking questions. Once a thought hardens into a belief, it becomes part of the lens the mind looks through. It decides what we notice, what we ignore, and what seems possible. The mind usually doesn't know it is wearing glasses at all.

This is why the mind needs wise direction. A mind always follows something. If the soul gives it a direction, it follows that direction. If nobody gives it one, it follows the oldest and loudest beliefs in the subconscious, many of which were picked up in childhood before we could judge them.

The Mind Looks for Proof

In 1960 the English psychologist Peter Wason gave people a simple game. He told them that the numbers 2, 4, 6 followed a secret rule, and he asked them to discover the rule by suggesting other sets of three numbers. Most people quickly guessed that the rule was "numbers going up by two." They then tested their guess by offering 8, 10, 12 and 20, 22, 24, which fit, and they announced their answer with confidence. They were wrong. The real rule was simply "any three numbers in rising order." Very few people tried a set such as 1, 2, 3 or 10, 5, 1, which could have shown them they were wrong. The mind naturally looks for evidence that it is right and seldom looks for evidence that it is wrong. Psychologists call this confirmation bias.

In 1979 Charles Lord, Lee Ross, and Mark Lepper at Stanford showed how strong this habit can be. They gave people who supported the death penalty and people who opposed it the same two studies, one that seemed to favor the death penalty and one that seemed to oppose it. Both sides picked apart the study they disagreed with and praised the one they agreed with. After reading exactly the same mixed evidence, each side was more sure of itself than before.

Automatic Thoughts

The psychiatrist Aaron Beck, who founded cognitive therapy in the 1960s, noticed that his depressed patients had quick, automatic thoughts that popped up in response to ordinary events. If a friend didn't call back, the thought "She doesn't care about me" arrived instantly, and it felt like a fact. Beck traced these thoughts back to deeper core beliefs, such as "I am unlovable." His student David Burns later listed the most common ways these thoughts bend the truth. They include all-or-nothing thinking, in which one mistake means total failure. They include mind reading, in which we are sure we know what others think of us. They include fortune telling, in which we predict disaster, and catastrophizing, in which a small problem is blown up into a terrible one. Most of us do all of these sometimes. The trouble begins when we stop noticing that we are doing them.

Different Parts Believe in Different Ways

The Gateway page made a useful distinction. The senses believe what they perceive directly. The emotions believe what they feel. The mind believes what it interprets. The soul believes what it knows to be true. These beliefs can disagree with each other. A person can know in the soul that she is loved while the mind keeps telling her otherwise. The soul's work is to sort out these conflicts and bring the beliefs into agreement. When that happens, the result is what this site calls coherence, a sense that the inner house has stopped arguing with itself.

Ignaz Semmelweis and the Washed Hands In 1847 Ignaz Semmelweis was a young doctor at the great hospital in Vienna. Women were dying of fever after childbirth at a frightening rate in the ward run by doctors, while far fewer died in the ward run by midwives. Semmelweis noticed that the doctors often came to the delivery room straight from performing autopsies. He ordered them to wash their hands in a chlorine solution first, and the death rate in his ward dropped sharply, to about one or two percent. The evidence was plain, but many senior doctors refused to accept it. Their belief that a gentleman's hands could not carry disease was stronger than the numbers in front of them, and germs had not yet been discovered to explain why washing worked. Semmelweis was pushed out of his post and died in 1865. His story shows that a belief can block the mind from seeing what it is looking right at, even in very intelligent people.

When Thinking Goes Wrong

A radio technician learns the most from a set that is not working right, and the study of the mind has learned in the same way. This section looks first at people whose thinking changed because of an injury or surgery. Then it looks at the more common ways thinking goes wrong in people whose brains are not injured at all. These are not strange problems that belong only to other people. Most of them are ordinary habits of the mind, turned up too loud.

Henry Molaison and the Permanent Present In 1953 a young man named Henry Molaison had brain surgery to stop his severe epileptic seizures. The surgeon, William Scoville, removed a part of the brain on both sides that includes the hippocampus. The seizures improved, but Henry could no longer form new long-term memories. He could hold a conversation, but if the other person left the room for a few minutes, he would greet them as a stranger when they returned. The psychologist Brenda Milner studied him for decades. She taught him to trace a star while looking only at its reflection in a mirror, a hard skill for anyone. Each day he got better at it, yet each day he said he had never done it before. His intelligence, his manners, and his sense of humor stayed whole. Henry died in 2008, and he taught the world that memory is not one thing. Remembering facts and events, learning skills, and simply being a thinking person are handled by different parts of the brain.
1

The Storyteller in the Left Brain

Some people with severe epilepsy have had the bundle of nerves between the two halves of the brain cut, so that each half works on its own. The neuroscientist Michael Gazzaniga showed one such patient a snowy scene to the right half of his brain and a chicken claw to the left half. His left hand pointed to a snow shovel, and his right hand pointed to a chicken. When asked why, the talking left half, which had never seen the snow, answered at once that the claw goes with the chicken and you need a shovel to clean out the chicken shed. He was not lying. He believed his explanation completely.This case shows that part of the mind makes up confident explanations, even when it doesn't know the real reason.

2

Stories Without Memories

People with Korsakoff syndrome, often caused by years of heavy drinking, lose much of their memory. When asked what they did yesterday, many give a detailed and sincere answer that never happened, such as a trip to the store or a visit from a cousin. Doctors call this confabulation. The person is not trying to fool anyone. The mind simply fills the hole with a story that seems right.This case shows that the mind would rather tell a story than admit an empty space.

3

Smart but Unable to Run Errands

In 1991 Tim Shallice and Paul Burgess studied three people with damage to the front of the brain. All three scored well on intelligence tests. Yet when they were sent out to do a few simple errands on a shopping street, such as buying a loaf of bread and finding out the price of tomatoes, they broke rules, forgot tasks, and wandered off course.This case shows that having thinking power and directing it are two different abilities.

4

The Arm That Is Fine

After some strokes on the right side of the brain, a person's left arm is paralyzed, and the person insists that the arm works perfectly. The French neurologist Joseph Babinski named this condition anosognosia in 1914. When asked to raise the arm, some patients say they are tired or that they just don't feel like it right now.This case shows that the mind will defend its story even against plain evidence.

Problems Without an Injury

Look at what those four cases have in common. In each one, the mind produced a story that felt completely true and was not. That same storytelling habit is at work in all of us, every day, in milder form. The rest of this section looks at some ways it goes wrong in people whose brains have no injury at all.

Jumping to Conclusions

In 1988 Sabina Huq, Philippa Garety, and David Hemsley in London invented a simple test using two jars of colored beads. One jar held mostly red beads and a few green ones. The other jar held the opposite. The researchers drew beads one at a time from a hidden jar and asked people to say which jar it was as soon as they felt sure. Most people waited to see several beads before deciding. Many people who held delusions, which are firm false beliefs, decided after seeing only one or two beads. Later studies found a milder version of the same habit in ordinary people who hold unusual beliefs. The quick-solution mind sees one bead and declares the case closed.

Why Conspiracy Ideas Pull Us In

Some conspiracies are real. Burglars working for President Nixon's reelection campaign really did break into the Watergate building, and tobacco companies really did hide what they knew about cancer for years. So the question is not whether people ever plot together. They do. The question is why some explanations grab hold of the mind even when the evidence is thin, and why they are so hard to let go.

In 2017 the psychologists Karen Douglas, Robbie Sutton, and Aleksandra Cichocka reviewed the research and found that conspiracy ideas meet three deep needs. The first is the need to understand. A secret plot is a clear, tidy story, and to the mind a tidy story feels better than "It was an accident" or "Nobody really knows." The second is the need to feel safe and in control. If bad things happen because of hidden villains, then at least somebody is in charge, and a person who knows the secret feels a little safer. The third is the need to feel good about ourselves and our group. Knowing what the "sheep" don't know makes a person feel special, and believing it together with others brings a sense of belonging. In 2008 Jennifer Whitson and Adam Galinsky found that when people were made to feel a loss of control, they were more likely to see patterns in random static and to suspect plots behind ordinary events. Later studies have found this effect to be smaller than first reported, but the basic idea holds up. A frightened mind goes looking for patterns, and it usually finds some.

A few signs suggest that an explanation is coming from the quick-solution mind rather than from careful thought. It explains everything and leaves no loose ends. Every piece of evidence against it is taken as more proof of the cover-up. It requires a very large number of people to keep a perfect secret for a very long time. And the person holding it cannot say what evidence would change their mind. A careful mind can usually answer that last question. A captured mind cannot.

Loops, What-Ifs, and Sticky Thoughts

Depression often traps the mind in loops. In 1991 the psychologist Susan Nolen-Hoeksema found that people who respond to a low mood by going over and over its causes and meanings stay depressed longer than people who turn their attention to something else. The mind believes that it is solving the problem, but it is only stirring it. Anxiety traps the mind in a different way, with an endless chain of "what ifs" about the future. Each answer raises a new question, and the mind never reaches the end of the chain.

Some thoughts are simply sticky. In 1978 Stanley Rachman and Padmal de Silva asked ordinary people, with no mental illness, whether they ever had unwanted thoughts that were strange, violent, or embarrassing. About eighty percent said yes. The thoughts themselves were much like the ones reported by people with obsessive-compulsive disorder. The difference was in how people treated them. Most people shrugged the thought off as mental noise. People with the disorder treated it as a dangerous message that had to be fought, checked, or undone, and the fighting made the thought come back stronger. A thought we refuse to give a microphone tends to wander off. A thought we argue with gets a bigger stage.

When the Mind Loses Touch

In psychosis, which can occur in schizophrenia, severe bipolar illness, and some drug reactions, the mind loses its grip on what is real. People may hear voices that others cannot hear or become certain of things that are not true. In 2003 the psychiatrist Shitij Kapur suggested one way to understand this. The brain's chemical signal for "Pay attention, this matters" fires too often, so ordinary events seem loaded with hidden meaning. The guessing system described in Section 1 begins to trust its own guesses over the senses. Psychosis is a medical illness, not a weakness of character, and it often responds well to treatment. Older adults can also become suddenly confused during an infection, after surgery, or because of a new medicine. Doctors call this delirium, and it is a reason to call a doctor right away, because it usually clears once the cause is treated.

A word of care

If you notice that your own thinking, or the thinking of someone you love, has changed in a worrying way, the kindest step is to talk with a doctor. Many of the problems on this page are treatable, and sudden changes can have simple physical causes.

The Mind Is a Storyteller

Every case in this section points to the same lesson. The mind is a storyteller first and a fact-checker second. It hates an empty space and fills it with the best story it can find, and then it believes the story. This is not a defect to be ashamed of. It is how the mind is built. But it means that a story feeling true is not the same as a story being true. Somebody inside us has to check. The next section shows who that is.

The Dispatcher and the Servant

The mind sits at a busy crossroads. The senses bring it reports, the ego asks what the reports mean for me, the emotions supply the energy, and the soul, when it is allowed to, sets the direction. R-Page 10 described one shared fuel that every part spends in its own way. The mind spends it one thought at a time, which is why where we point the mind matters so much.

S

Senses

The senses feed the mind its raw material, and the mind's guesses decide what the senses notice. We tend to see what we already expect to see.

E

Ego

The ego often hires the mind as its lawyer. Whatever the ego counts as ours, including our opinions, the mind is quick to defend.

E

Emotions

The mind tells the emotions what is going on, and the emotions give thoughts their weight. A thought with strong feeling behind it keeps coming back.

S

Soul

The soul gives the mind its direction and checks its stories. When the soul leads, the mind becomes a faithful servant instead of a noisy roommate.

Emotion Gives Thought Its Power

The Gateway page pointed out that many thoughts would fade quickly if emotion did not feed them. Fear produces fear-thoughts, anger produces argument-thoughts, and shame produces self-attack. In 1981 the psychologist Gordon Bower showed that mood even steers memory. People in a sad mood remembered more sad events from their lives, and people in a happy mood remembered more happy ones. This creates a loop. A low mood calls up gloomy memories, the gloomy memories feed gloomy thoughts, and the gloomy thoughts deepen the mood. The weight a thought carries comes from the feeling behind it, but weight is not proof.

The Ego Hires a Lawyer

In 1990 the psychologist Ziva Kunda reviewed the research on what she called motivated reasoning. When people want a conclusion to be true, they reason toward it. They do not ignore the evidence completely, but they search harder for support, accept weak arguments that agree with them, and pick apart strong arguments that don't. The ego decides what it wants to be true, and the mind goes to work building the case. Most of the time we have no idea this is happening, because from the inside it feels exactly like careful thinking.

The Background Hum

The ego, the emotions, and the mind together build the background hum that carries us toward whatever we focus on. The mind's part in the hum is its running commentary. A mind that keeps telling a story of grievance tunes the hum to resentment. A mind that keeps returning to good work, to learning, and to the people it loves tunes the hum toward energy and care. The hum suffers when we are sick, when bad things happen, and when the mind goes through long stretches with nothing worth doing.

The Soul Directs, and the Mind Serves

The Gateway page described what happens when the soul steps out of the picture. The mind becomes mechanical, and the ego either takes over or lets the mind run things. Sometimes no decision gets made at all, and the whole system drifts in a dazed confusion. When the senses, the ego, the emotions, or the mind try to lead, the lightweights are running the show, and nobody sees the big picture. The answer is not to silence the mind. It is to put the mind back in its proper job. The soul watches what the mind is saying, and it often disagrees. It asks whether the story is true, whether it is kind, and whether it is worth following. Then it gives the mind a better task. Psychologists call the ability to think about our own thinking metacognition, and it is one of the best predictors of good judgment. In the language of this site, it is the soul doing its work.

Give the Mind a Job, Then Let It Rest

R-Page 12, Optimization, summed up the care of the mind in four words, which were "solve, then let go." The mind does its best work when it has a real problem in front of it, and it does its worst work when it has nothing to do. The practices below help with both halves of that rule.

Solve, Then Release

In 1927 the Russian psychologist Bluma Zeigarnik noticed that waiters remembered unpaid orders perfectly and forgot them the moment the bill was paid. She found in experiments that people remember unfinished tasks better than finished ones. An unfinished task keeps tugging at the mind. In 2011 E. J. Masicampo and Roy Baumeister found a simple way to stop the tugging. When people with an unfinished goal wrote down a specific plan for when and how they would finish it, the nagging thoughts faded, even though the task itself was still undone. The mind only needed to know that the job was handled.

R-Page 12 also described the difference between reflection and rumination, drawn by Paul Trapnell and Jennifer Campbell in 1999. Reflection is curious, and it reaches an end. Rumination is anxious, and it goes around in circles. The mind should remember the past long enough to learn its lesson and plan the future long enough to prepare for it. Then it should let both go.

Purpose Is Medicine

The Gateway page said that the mind needs something to figure out, whether it is simple or complex. Chopping wood, tending a plant, organizing a drawer, writing a paragraph, or fixing something small can bring the mind back into service. The psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi spent years studying people who were deeply absorbed in their work, from rock climbers to surgeons to factory workers. In his 1990 book Flow, he reported that people are often happiest not while relaxing but while fully engaged in a task that stretches their skill. In that state, which he called flow, the worrying voice goes quiet because the mind is busy with something worth doing.

Thinking Is Like Writing

A good piece of writing has three qualities. It flows, which means each sentence leads to the next. It is clear, which means the reader knows exactly what is being said. And it is reasonable, which means it holds up when someone checks it. Good thinking needs the same three qualities. A muddled thought jumps from one idea to another, uses vague words, and never gets checked. A good thought moves step by step, says plainly what it means, and stands up to a fair look at the evidence.

Writing a thought down is one of the best ways to find out whether it is any good. In 2002 Leonid Rozenblit and Frank Keil asked people how well they understood everyday objects such as a zipper or a flush toilet. Most people rated their understanding as quite good. Then the researchers asked them to explain, step by step, exactly how the object works. Most people got stuck, and afterward they rated their understanding much lower. The researchers called this the illusion of explanatory depth. In 2013 Philip Fernbach and his colleagues tried the same thing with political issues. When people with strong opinions were asked to explain step by step how a policy would actually work, many discovered gaps in their understanding, and their opinions became less extreme. Explaining forced the mind to slow down. The physicist Richard Feynman put the whole lesson into one sentence in 1974, when he told a graduating class at Caltech that you must not fool yourself, and that you are the easiest person to fool.

A thought that jumps

The Quick Story

"My neighbor didn't wave this morning. He must be angry about the fence. He's probably been talking to the others about me, too."

A thought that flows

The Checked Story

"My neighbor didn't wave this morning. I don't know why. He may not have seen me, or he may have had something on his mind. Nothing else suggests he is upset, so I will wave first next time and see."

Try it: edit a thought the way you would edit a page

  1. Write the thought down in one plain sentence.
  2. Write out the steps that led you to it, one sentence each.
  3. Look at each step and ask how you know it is true.
  4. Think of at least one other explanation that would also fit the facts.
  5. Ask what evidence would change your mind. If you can't think of any, be suspicious of the thought.
  6. If the matter is important, sleep on it and read it again in the morning.

Chanting and Repeated Phrases

The Gateway page suggested giving the mind something peaceful to rest on, such as the breath or a phrase like "Be still." Nearly every spiritual tradition has a version of this, from the Jesus Prayer of the Eastern Orthodox monks to the mantras of India and the rosary. In 2015 Aviva Berkovich-Ohana and her colleagues in Israel scanned people's brains while they silently repeated a single word. The repetition quieted much of the default mode network, the same idle network that produces so much mental chatter. Chanting works because it gives the mind a small, simple job. The mind is busy enough to stop wandering, and calm enough to rest.

Give the Mind a Real Rest

The Gateway page made an important point, which is that letting the mind wander is not the same as resting it. True rest happens when awareness is present but the mind has no job to perform. Thoughts may still appear, but they are not hired, followed, or fed. Meditation teaches this skill, and it works best with some education about what we are looking at, which is part of what this site is for. Stepping back to watch the mind is not perfect, but it is the main tool we have.

Nature helps too. In 2008 Marc Berman, John Jonides, and Stephen Kaplan at the University of Michigan sent people on a walk either through a tree-filled park or along busy city streets. The people who walked among the trees scored noticeably better afterward on a test of attention. Kaplan believed that natural scenes hold our attention gently, without demanding anything, which lets the mind's tired focusing system recover. Sleep and short naps help as well. In 1995 a NASA study found that airline pilots who were allowed a short nap during long flights were more alert and performed better than pilots who stayed awake.

Finally, the mind needs fun and silliness between its times of hard work and deep insight. A joke, a game, a song, or an afternoon with nothing to solve is not wasted time. It is the pause that lets the next good thought arrive.

A Faithful Servant of Truth

The mind is the part of us that reasons, plans, explains, and builds. It works in a narrow channel, one thought at a time, and it is always guessing about what comes next. The body sets its floor through sleep, stress, food, movement, and whatever chemicals we put into it. Beliefs steer it from above, often without our knowing. When thinking breaks, whether from an injury, an illness, or an ordinary habit turned up too loud, the same lesson appears again and again. The mind is a storyteller, and it believes its own stories.

The good news is that the mind can be trained and cared for. We can give it real work, write its thoughts down and check them the way we would edit a page, finish or plan its unfinished business, and give it simple, peaceful things to rest on. Most of all, we can let the soul direct it. A directed mind bears fruit, and a rested mind is ready to bear more.

The mind was never meant to run the house. Given a good master and a real task, it becomes one of the finest servants a person could ask for.

Sources & Further Reading

  1. 01 George A. Miller, "The Magical Number Seven, Plus or Minus Two," Psychological Review (1956); Nelson Cowan, "The Magical Number 4 in Short-Term Memory," Behavioral and Brain Sciences (2001).
  2. 02 Joshua S. Rubinstein, David E. Meyer, and Jeffrey E. Evans, "Executive Control of Cognitive Processes in Task Switching," Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance (2001).
  3. 03 Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow (2011).
  4. 04 Shane Frederick, "Cognitive Reflection and Decision Making," Journal of Economic Perspectives (2005) — the bat-and-ball problem.
  5. 05 Andy Clark, Surfing Uncertainty: Prediction, Action, and the Embodied Mind (2016) — predictive processing.
  6. 06 Marcus E. Raichle et al., "A Default Mode of Brain Function," PNAS (2001).
  7. 07 Matthew A. Killingsworth and Daniel T. Gilbert, "A Wandering Mind Is an Unhappy Mind," Science (2010).
  8. 08 Jonathan Haidt, The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion (2012).
  9. 09 Hans P. A. Van Dongen, Greg Maislin, Janet M. Mullington, and David F. Dinges, "The Cumulative Cost of Additional Wakefulness," Sleep (2003).
  10. 10 A. M. Williamson and Anne-Marie Feyer, "Moderate Sleep Deprivation Produces Impairments in Cognitive and Motor Performance Equivalent to Legally Prescribed Levels of Alcohol Intoxication," Occupational and Environmental Medicine (2000).
  11. 11 Amy F. T. Arnsten, "Stress Signalling Pathways That Impair Prefrontal Cortex Structure and Function," Nature Reviews Neuroscience (2009).
  12. 12 Kirk I. Erickson et al., "Exercise Training Increases Size of Hippocampus and Improves Memory," PNAS (2011).
  13. 13 John L. Horn and Raymond B. Cattell, "Age Differences in Fluid and Crystallized Intelligence," Acta Psychologica (1967).
  14. 14 Claude M. Steele and Robert A. Josephs, "Alcohol Myopia: Its Prized and Dangerous Effects," American Psychologist (1990).
  15. 15 Aaron M. White, "What Happened? Alcohol, Memory Blackouts, and the Brain," Alcohol Research & Health (2003).
  16. 16 Madeline H. Meier et al., "Persistent Cannabis Users Show Neuropsychological Decline from Childhood to Midlife," PNAS (2012).
  17. 17 Marta Di Forti et al., "The Contribution of Cannabis Use to Variation in the Incidence of Psychotic Disorder Across Europe," The Lancet Psychiatry (2019).
  18. 18 American Geriatrics Society, the Beers Criteria for Potentially Inappropriate Medication Use in Older Adults (updated regularly).
  19. 19 Peter C. Wason, "On the Failure to Eliminate Hypotheses in a Conceptual Task," Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology (1960).
  20. 20 Charles G. Lord, Lee Ross, and Mark R. Lepper, "Biased Assimilation and Attitude Polarization," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (1979).
  21. 21 Aaron T. Beck, Cognitive Therapy and the Emotional Disorders (1976); David D. Burns, Feeling Good: The New Mood Therapy (1980).
  22. 22 Sherwin B. Nuland, The Doctors' Plague: Germs, Childbed Fever, and the Strange Story of Ignác Semmelweis (2003).
  23. 23 William B. Scoville and Brenda Milner, "Loss of Recent Memory After Bilateral Hippocampal Lesions," Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry (1957); Suzanne Corkin, Permanent Present Tense (2013).
  24. 24 Michael S. Gazzaniga and Joseph E. LeDoux, The Integrated Mind (1978); Michael S. Gazzaniga, Who's in Charge? Free Will and the Science of the Brain (2011).
  25. 25 Michael D. Kopelman, "Varieties of Confabulation and Delusion," Cognitive Neuropsychiatry (2010) — confabulation in Korsakoff syndrome.
  26. 26 Tim Shallice and Paul W. Burgess, "Deficits in Strategy Application Following Frontal Lobe Damage in Man," Brain (1991).
  27. 27 Joseph Babinski (1914), on anosognosia; V. S. Ramachandran and Sandra Blakeslee, Phantoms in the Brain (1998).
  28. 28 S. F. Huq, P. A. Garety, and D. R. Hemsley, "Probabilistic Judgements in Deluded and Non-Deluded Subjects," Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology (1988).
  29. 29 Karen M. Douglas, Robbie M. Sutton, and Aleksandra Cichocka, "The Psychology of Conspiracy Theories," Current Directions in Psychological Science (2017).
  30. 30 Jennifer A. Whitson and Adam D. Galinsky, "Lacking Control Increases Illusory Pattern Perception," Science (2008).
  31. 31 Susan Nolen-Hoeksema, "Responses to Depression and Their Effects on the Duration of Depressive Episodes," Journal of Abnormal Psychology (1991).
  32. 32 S. Rachman and P. de Silva, "Abnormal and Normal Obsessions," Behaviour Research and Therapy (1978).
  33. 33 Shitij Kapur, "Psychosis as a State of Aberrant Salience," American Journal of Psychiatry (2003); Sharon K. Inouye, "Delirium in Older Persons," New England Journal of Medicine (2006).
  34. 34 Gordon H. Bower, "Mood and Memory," American Psychologist (1981).
  35. 35 Ziva Kunda, "The Case for Motivated Reasoning," Psychological Bulletin (1990).
  36. 36 Bluma Zeigarnik, on the memory of finished and unfinished tasks (1927); E. J. Masicampo and Roy F. Baumeister, "Consider It Done! Plan Making Can Eliminate the Cognitive Effects of Unfulfilled Goals," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2011).
  37. 37 Paul D. Trapnell and Jennifer D. Campbell, "Private Self-Consciousness and the Five-Factor Model of Personality," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (1999) — reflection and rumination.
  38. 38 Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience (1990).
  39. 39 Leonid Rozenblit and Frank Keil, "The Misunderstood Limits of Folk Science: An Illusion of Explanatory Depth," Cognitive Science (2002); Philip M. Fernbach, Todd Rogers, Craig R. Fox, and Steven A. Sloman, "Political Extremism Is Supported by an Illusion of Understanding," Psychological Science (2013).
  40. 40 Richard P. Feynman, "Cargo Cult Science," Caltech commencement address (1974).
  41. 41 Aviva Berkovich-Ohana et al., "Repetitive Speech Elicits Widespread Deactivation in the Human Cortex: The 'Mantra' Effect?" Brain and Behavior (2015).
  42. 42 Marc G. Berman, John Jonides, and Stephen Kaplan, "The Cognitive Benefits of Interacting with Nature," Psychological Science (2008).
  43. 43 Mark R. Rosekind et al., Crew Factors in Flight Operations IX: Effects of Planned Cockpit Rest on Crew Performance and Alertness in Long-Haul Operations, NASA Technical Memorandum (1994–1995).

Where to Go Next

The mind reads what is going on and tells the story. The last part of SEEMS is the soul, which watches the story, checks whether it is true, and gives the mind its direction.

Continue to The Soul Deep Study Page

Back to The Mind Gateway Page  ·  Back to The Emotions Deep Study Page  ·  Back to The Five Pillars